Advertisement

ketogenic Diet - Is it more harmful than beneficial

ketogenic Diet - Is it more harmful than beneficial
ketogenic Diet - Is it more harmful than beneficial



A "ketogenic diet" usually refers to a diet with very low carbohydrate content, moderate protein content, and high fat content, designed to induce ketosis or ketones. as an alternative energy source for neurons and other cells that cannot metabolize fatty acids directly, urinary ketone levels are often used as an indicator of dietary compliance. the "classic" ketogenic diet usually refers to a medically supervised diet with a ratio of 4:1 to dietary protein and carbohydrate.

Recently, researchers at the American Association of Responsible Physicians, New York University, the University of Pennsylvania, George Washington University and Bellevue Hospital in New York conducted a comprehensive assessment of the ketogenic diet, weighing the pros and cons of the ketogenic diet against chronic diseases. The review was published in Frontiers in Nutrition.

During long-term fasting, some tissues can metabolize free fatty acids released from fat storage directly. most of these fatty acids are converted into ketones in the liver, which provide fuel to glucose consumers such as neurons, minimizing the mobilization of proteins in the body to glycogenicity. a ketogenic diet changes protein utilization: the body diverts as much protein as possible to sugar heterogeneity, while using the minimum amount necessary for tissue repair.


Extreme carbohydrate restrictions can have a profound impact on diet quality, especially by reducing or not eating fruits, vegetables, whole grains and legumes, and increasing animal foods. in the absence of multivitamin supplements, people on a low-carbohydrate diet are at significant risk of nutritional deficiencies, and other protective dietary ingredients, such as phytochemicals, may be inadequate.

studies have shown that the "improved" ketogenic diet allows for more carbohydrates and is somewhat effective in reducing seizures. about 1/3 to 1/2 of drug-resistant epilepsy patients can reduce the frequency of seizures by at least 50% through a ketogenic diet. however, most studies are not long-term, large-scale and lack adult involvement.


As for the idea that a ketogenic diet can lead to weight loss, studies suggest that weight loss from a ketogenic diet may be due to loss of appetite, and that the effect is also seen in those who follow a balanced, very low-energy diet (< 800 kcal/day). since ketosis occurs in both diets, it is assumed that ketosis itself may reduce hunger. a low-fat vegetarian diet may be more effective at suppressing appetite than a ketogenic diet, according to a new study.


Although a ketogenic diet can improve blood sugar in people with type 1 diabetes, it is generally not used in these populations due to the risks of malnutrition, stunting, reduced bone density, hyperlipidemia, poor sleep, amenorrhea and hypoglycemia. A small study of 11 adults with type 1 diabetes showed that the ketogenic diet improved blood sugar control but triggered more frequent and extreme low blood sugar attacks (6.3 times a week, usually 1 to2 times a week for people following a regular or other unspecified diet),and most participants also developed symptoms of lipid abnormalities.

A ketogenic diet suppresses appetite in the short term, promotes weight loss, lowers blood sugar levels, and lowers glycoglobin. Some studies have shown that improving insulin sensitivity seems to depend on reduced fat levels. However, a recent analysis of the data shows that after a few months of restricting a carbohydrate diet, the decline in hemoglobin A1c is usually reduced, and this diet is no more effective than other diets.

In epidemiological studies, diets high in saturated fat, trans fats, monosaccharides and animal proteins (especially from red and processed meats), low dietary fiber, and omega-3 fatty acids are considered to be responsible for the occurrence of non-alcoholic fatty liver (NAFLD). Excess fat stored in liver cells, leading to sclerosis, can develop into non-alcoholic fatty hepatitis, increases the risk of hepatocellular carcinoma, and has a significantly higher risk of NAFLD from obesity or type 2 diabetes.

Some clinical trials compared low-fat and low-carbohydrate, low-calorie diets in overweight or obese adults and found similar reductions in intra-liver fat. a ketogenic diet usually increases intake of saturated fat, cholesterol, and animal protein, all of which are associated with increased insulin resistance, oxidative stress, and increased flow of free fatty acids to liver cells. it has been suggested that ketosis may be beneficial for the treatment of fatty livers, but energy intake is usually restricted and long-term safety and specific clinical outcomes have not yet been determined.

It is important to note that, where the long-term benefits of a ketogenic diet for diabetes and obesity are not yet clear, one of the greatest potential risks of a ketogenic diet is kidney stones for people without chronic kidney disease (CKD). The ketogenic diet emphasizes high-fat, animal foods, excluding many fruits and vegetables, and promotes the urinary environment of kidney stones. Eating animal protein is a good promoter of kidney stone formation, and acidosis caused by the ketogenic diet may promote the formation of stones by lowering uric acid and pH while increasing calcium levels in the urine.


For CKD patients, high protein intake in the ketogenic diet promotes high filtration (an increase in blood flow to the renal glomerular), and the acid load on the ketogenic diet may aggravate metabolic acidosis and kidney disease in CKD patients. The acid load on the ketogenic diet comes from the ketoacids associated with ketogenic production in the food consumed (especially animal foods) and the lack of natural alkalis (no fruits and vegetables) in the ketogenic diet. Therefore, the ketogenic diet needs further research on the long-term kidney safety of CKD patients and non-CKD patients.

In addition, the study found that infants with neural tube defects (especially anencephaly and spina bifida) who ate a low-carbohydrate diet in the year prior to conception were 30 percent more likely. in particular, for unplanned pregnancies, estimates of the effects of carbohydrate-restricted diets show an 89 percent increased risk of neural tube defects.

Is a ketogenic diet more beneficial than harmful or more harmful than beneficial?

 A ketogenic diet can reduce the frequency of seizures in some drug-resistant epilepsy patients and reduce weight, but in the long run, it is no more effective than other dietary methods. a ketogenic diet can also lower blood sugar, although its negative effects usually weaken in the first few months.

Very low-carbohydrate diets have a clear risk: LDL-C sometimes rises sharply, and pregnant women who use this diet are more likely to give birth to children with neural tube defects, and a ketogenic diet may increase the risk of chronic diseases: the usually increased food and dietary components in a ketogenic diet (e.g. red meat, processed meat, saturated fat) increase the risk of CKD, cardiovascular disease, cancer, diabetes and Alzheimer's disease, while protective foods (e.g. vegetables, fruits, Beans, whole grains) are usually consumed less.


Combining the above studies and discussions, it is concluded that for most people, the risks of this diet outweigh the benefits.

Post a Comment

0 Comments